Mazars launches 2021 ‘Responsible banking practices benchmark study’ - finds significant progress on sustainable finance globally but full implementation remains work in progress
- 37 banks based in Africa, the Americas, Asia-Pacific and Europe assessed to identify best practice and trends in their management of climate change risk and broader social and governance issues
- Banks have made progress across all assessed sustainable finance dimensions since 2020 edition of the study
- Average percentage of banks developing a responsible product offering is 82% - compared to 47% last year
8 March 2021: Mazars, the international tax, audit and advisory firm, launches the 2021 edition of its annual Responsible banking practices benchmark study. The global study assesses the sustainability practices of 37 of the world’s largest banks1 based in Europe, Africa, the Americas, Asia-Pacific.
The analysis shows that the banking industry now widely acknowledges opportunities and risks relating to sustainability matters. However, full implementation of practices designed to achieve sustainability objectives remains a work in progress.
Global findings: banks make notable progress on sustainability
The global analysis shows that most banks assessed:
- Foster a culture of sustainability and allocate responsibility for this to senior management functions. On average, 74% of banks have implemented measures that foster a culture of sustainability and adapted their governance structure, compared to 49% last year. However, integration of ESG skills in selecting board composition, and the measurement of ESG performance when setting remuneration, remain infrequent practices.
- Commit to SMART targets for sustainability, with climate-related targets the most prevalent. Methodologies for strategic alignment with the Paris Agreement have gained traction: some 51% of banks are piloting the PACTA methodology to align their financial portfolios with the Paris Agreement objectives. However, this has yet to be reflected in banks’ official commitments to climate neutrality.
- Have risk management practices that are more advanced for climate risks than for broader ESG risks – with most building climate scenario analysis capabilities. However, the financial impact of climate change on banks remains challenging to measure due to a lack of quantitative information. Only 22% of banks provide quantitative data on the materiality of climate risks.
- Implement sustainability reporting standards, mostly focused on climate objectives, with CDP and TCFD recommendations the most common. In terms of metrics and targets, GHG emissions are the most reported. A key reporting challenge remains Scope 3 GHG emissions; only 11% of banks disclose matters in relation to their financing activities.
- Have a corporate offering that is more mature than the offering for individuals, and climate and environmental products are more prevalent than economic and social products. For example, 78% of banks have developed a green bond offering, whereas only 32% have developed green products for individuals. Comparing banks’ offerings remains a challenge due to a lack of standardised reporting frameworks.
Leila Kamdem-Fotso, Partner, Mazars says: “It is clear that banks are increasingly committed to making their practices more sustainable, and this has led to progress since our first study. The findings are encouraging, but they also reveal the work that remains to be done. Banks need to fully implement relevant practices, particularly in climate risk management and disclosures, if they are to meet sustainability objectives. One way of doing this is to improve methodologies and better quantify incurred climate-related impacts in their reporting. Positive developments in this area could allow banks to fully play their role in shaping a more sustainable future for the global economy.”
Improvements across all areas: 2021 vs 2020
Comparing the recent results with our 2020 assessment, banks have made progress across all of the sustainable finance dimensions analysed:
- The average percentage of banks developing a responsible product offering is now 82%, compared to 47% last year.
- Banks that foster a culture of sustainability and have updated their governance structures accordingly is up by half (51%) while there is a similar increase (45%) in the percentage of banks that align their disclosures with ESG reporting standards.
- There are clear lags in areas such as embedding ESG and climate criteria into risk management frameworks and implementing strategies for sustainability (22% and 20% increase, respectively).
French and UK banks lead on culture, governance, strategy and offering
French and UK banks take a leading position on culture and governance, strategy and the development of a responsible product offering. Banks from both countries score highly on the alignment of disclosures with ESG reporting standards and integration of ESG risks in risk management frameworks. There is room for improvement on the use of climate scenario analysis for risk management purposes and on disclosures. The Bank of England, Banque de France and the European Central Bank are all increasing their focus on these areas.
North American banks perform well on ESG disclosures and more
North American banks perform well on governance, strategy, ESG disclosures, and responsible product offering. North American banks have done well in the implementation of ESG disclosures, where they have outperformed French and UK banks on average. As with French and UK banks, there is still room for better integration of ESG risks into their risk management framework.
South American banks stand out for governance and sustainability
South American banks perform well on governance and sustainability. But they need to work on the integration of ESG risks, including climate risks within their risk management frameworks, and the development of a responsible product offering.
Asia-Pacific banks perform well on product offering
Asia-Pacific banks perform particularly well with respect to their responsible product offering. Two-thirds of these banks propose sustainable services and products across all their business lines. Overall scores for the region show room for improvement on strategy, risk management and disclosures. In Hong Kong, New Zealand and Australia, new regulation is expected to build climate resilience and effective disclosures and will likely develop a more systematic approach to sustainability.
“The practice of reporting non-financial information concerning sustainability by banks in Poland is not uniform. We know banks that prepare extensive separate responsible business reports and have them assessed by statutory auditors as part of an assurance engagement. Such practice is quite common in Western European countries and we expect this trend to gain traction also in Poland” says Małgorzata Pek-Kocik, Mazars Partner responsible for services for the financial institution sector. “However, most Polish banks have a lesson to learn, in particular with respect to integration of ESG risks in their risk management framework and precise definition of SMART objectives, especially to mitigate the risk of climate change. The results of the survey conducted by Mazars in 2021 may be a useful hint for banks in Poland in which direction they should develop their sustainability reporting” she adds.
1The banks selected are the largest in their respective geographies based on their total assets
The Mazars benchmark assesses the sustainability practices of a sample of 37 banks. We have focused our analysis on banks based in Africa, the Americas, Asia-Pacific and Europe. The banks selected are the largest in their respective geographies by total assets.
Most of the banks selected have demonstrated a significant interest in sustainability and climate change by implementing frameworks, participating in the United Nations Environment Programme Finance Initiative (UNEP FI), and/or committing to the UNEP FI Principles for Responsible Banking (PRB). This study builds on previous Mazars reports published in 2020: “Responsible banking practices, benchmark study” and “How banks are responding to the financial risks of climate change”.
Edward Baggaley, Global Campaigns Manager: Edward.email@example.com // +44 (0)78 2408 6578
Renata Stefanowska, Marketing and Communications Manager, Mazars in Poland: firstname.lastname@example.org // +48 22 25 55 200
Mazars is an internationally integrated partnership, specialising in audit, accountancy, advisory, tax and legal services*. Operating in over 90 countries and territories around the world, we draw on the expertise of more than 42,000 professionals – 26,000+ in Mazars’ integrated partnership and 16,000+ via the Mazars North America Alliance – to assist clients of all sizes at every stage in their development.
Mazars has been operating in Poland since 1992, currently employs over 300 specialists in Warsaw and Krakow and serves over 800 Polish and international companies of various sizes, offering them a full range of services in the fields of audit, accounting, HR & payroll consultancy, tax, consulting and financial advisory.
*where permitted under applicable country laws
www.mazars.com | linkedin.com/company/mazars | twitter.com/mazarsgroup
www.pol.mazars.pl | linkedin.com/company/mazars-in-poland